So Planned Parenthood is in some really hot water because they got caught explaining how they sell organs from abortions performed at PP facilities. It turns out evil likes red wine with salad.
The biology of the matter is simply damning for the abortion-choice case. The “it’s just tissue or clumps of cells” line dies a prompt death when it’s possible to specify particular organs far below 20 weeks of pregnancy. That tissue has to be alive, which infers that the being that it came from was a living, organized whole that is literally dis-organized–in both senses of the term–for profit. The essential humanity of the unborn is cast in stark relief because of this practice.
One comment that was food for thought was the question of consent. Do mothers consent to have the remains of the fetus used in medical research? Is this on the forms? If not, why not? Who would knowingly do such a thing? And who would willingly try to claim that even though the unborn is a human being that has been dissected for research, that doing so is morally acceptable because they are just at that stage of development?
Planned Parenthood also released a small statement attempting to defend this barbaric practice. I am sure it sounded better in the original German. Unsurprisingly they pulled a card from the defenders of embryonic stem cell research, claiming that it is used to create cures and treatments. News flash: it is still wrong, even if used towards good ends.
During the trial of Kermit Gosnell, PP spent quite a lot of time trying to explain how Gosnell’s practice was separate from PP and their own clinics were held to better standards. It would seem that the difference between PP’s highest echelons of leadership and Gosnell is that Gosnell kept his own collection of aborted fetuses while Planned Parenthood sold them. It has been suggested that this is their Gosnell moment and that might well be the case.
The media is silent. When they do decide to talk about it, they will frame it as an unfair attack on Planned Parenthood. Those evil Bible-thumping theocrats won’t let them sell aborted livers and hearts and heads for research!
That silence is deplorable since the sale of body parts described both in the video and the statement is patently illegal, and the Senior Director admitted that they were trying to keep the lawyers mostly out of the loop and make it otherwise covert. I wonder why? As if we didn’t have enough reasons to consider Planned parenthood a criminal organization, we have another huge reason to consider them one.
I still don’t think I approve of using hidden video for things like this. I think they weaken (to an extent) the overall moral case of those who engage in it. Nevertheless it does not affect the case against abortion…and certainly not selling fetal organs.
About that media silence: I cannot help but feel like we have morphed into some sort of cultural Stalinism. The media has, by and large, become the new Pravda, and their power to declare truths has gotten us to the point where Planned Parenthood can sell aborted fetal remains and it’s only controversial because other people got the word out. The possibility of truth, it seems, has all but died in American culture, and even if the media parrots some giant lie, people grumble, admit it’s a lie, but they are not challenged. And so it continues.
Perry Noble’s ignorant, snide comments don’t look so loving now, do they? I wonder if he considers Planned Parenthood more loving than Christians after this?